After Goodluck India, the Interest Paid Under Rule 96(10) Must Come Back

19-11-2026 Adv.Venkatanaryana GM

Few provisions of the GST law have generated as much litigation as Rule 96(10) of the CGST Rules. Introduced with effect from 23.10.2017, it barred refund of IGST paid on exports where the exporter, or its supplier, had procured inputs under specified concessions such as Advance Authorisation, EPCG and EOU notifications. Rules 89(4A) and 89(4B) operated on parallel lines on the ITC refund side. The rule was amended more than once, including by a retrospective Explanation, and the Kerala High Court in Sance Laboratories went to the extent of holding it ultra vires Section 16 of the IGST Act.

Faced with audit objections, many exporters chose not to litigate. They repaid the IGST refund along with interest under Section 50, in cash, through FORM GST DRC-03. Rule 86(4B), inserted by Notification No. 14/2022-CT dated 05.07.2022, and Circular No. 174/06/2022-GST dated 06.07.2022 then permitted the principal to be re-credited to the electronic credit ledger by an order in FORM GST PMT-03A. The interest, however, remained with the Government. The question this article addresses is whether that interest is now refundable.

The effects of omission

The 54th GST Council, recommended omission of Rules 96(10), 89(4A) and 89(4B) with prospective effect. Notification No. 20/2024-CT omitted them from 08.10.2024, but without any saving or sunset clause. The department read the Council's word "prospective" into the notification and continued to pursue demands for the earlier period. The Gujarat High Court in Addwrap Packaging and connected matters took the contrary view, relying on Fibre Boards (P) Ltd. v. CIT (2015) 10 SCC 333, and held that the omission governs all pending proceedings.

The supreme court rules in Goodluck India

In Goodluck India Ltd. v. Union of India, SLP (C) No. 24550 of 2025, decided on 06.08.2026, the Supreme Court affirmed that view. Applying the Constitution Bench decision in Kolhapur Canesugar Works Ltd. v. Union of India (2000) 2 SCC 536, the Court held that proceedings under an omitted rule can continue only where a saving provision or legal fiction keeps them alive. No such provision accompanied the omission of Rule 96(10), and the Council's recommendation of prospective effect was only advisory. The omission therefore applies to every proceeding pending on 08.10.2024. CBIC accepted the judgment by Office Memorandum dated 24.08.2026.

The 57th GST Council and Circular 264

The 57th GST Council, meeting on 08.10.2026, recommended that the omission be effective from 23.10.2017 in line with the Supreme Court's decision. CBIC followed with Circular No. 264/10/2026-GST dated 26.10.2026, issued under Section 168(1). The circular states that the omission will be effective retrospectively from 23.10.2017, directs field formations to deal with pending proceedings in accordance with Goodluck India, and extends the same treatment to Rules 89(4A) and 89(4B).

The circular, notably, goes further than the judgment. The Court spoke of proceedings pending on the date of omission; the Board speaks of retrospective effect from the very date the rule was introduced. For the exporter who complied early and paid, that wider wording is the opening.

Why the interest is refundable

The first and simplest answer is that interest cannot survive without a principal. Interest under Section 50 is compensatory and accessory to tax that is due. If Rule 96(10) is treated as never having existed, the IGST refund originally granted was never erroneous, its repayment was never owed, and no interest could accrue on it. The Supreme Court in Pratibha Processors v. Union of India (1996) 11 SCC 101 recognised that interest is accessory to the principal and falls with it.

Secondly, Article 265 forbids retention of any amount collected without authority of law. Once the Board itself declares that the restriction is to be treated as omitted from 23.10.2017, the interest collected on its supposed breach has no surviving legal basis.

Thirdly, a circular under Section 168 binds the field formations, as held in Paper Products Ltd. v. CCE (1999) 7 SCC 84 and Ratan Melting & Wire Industries (2008) 13 SCC 1, and a beneficial circular operates retrospectively, as held in Suchitra Components Ltd. v. CCE (2007) 11 SCC 108. The department cannot invoke Circular 264 to drop pending demands and at the same time refuse its benefit to the exporter who paid without contest.

Fourthly, Rule 86(4B) and Circular 174 themselves presuppose a refund obtained "in contravention of" Rule 96(10). With the rule treated as omitted from inception, there was no contravention, and the condition of paying interest for re-credit loses its foundation. Finally, the bar of unjust enrichment does not arise, since interest is never passed on to a buyer and refund of tax on exports falls under Section 54(8)(a).

The closest judicial support is the recent decision of the Bombay High Court in Leben Laboratories v. Union of India. The exporter there had repaid additional customs duty on imports under Advance Authorisation, with interest of about 43 lakh, to retain its IGST refund. Relying on Goodluck India, the Court held that Rule 96(10) is deemed omitted since inception, that there was therefore no legal obligation to make the repayment, and that the question of interest could not arise. Refund of the interest was directed. Though that case arose on the customs route, its reasoning applies squarely to interest paid through DRC-03 on the GST route.

Conclusion

The honest exporter who repaid with interest should not end up worse off than the one who chose to litigate. The appropriate course is to file a refund application in RFD-01 for the interest deposited through DRC-03, relying on Goodluck India, the Office Memorandum dated 24.08.2026, Circular 264 and Leben Laboratories, and to claim interest on delayed refund under Section 56. If the claim is rejected on limitation or as a closed matter, the High Court under Article 226 remains the remedy.